The problem with Datacentres

One way or another, we are all consumers of datacentre services. Whether we watch YouTube content, read e-mail from outlook.com, or look at news websites  every piece of information that reaches our eyes was stored at (or passed through) one or more datacentres.

Everyone has their own idea of what a datacentre actually is. For most people this is rows or racks, containing power protected high-end servers  lots of cables and flashing lights.

The Cooling Challenge

At a recent 'Uptime Institute' event, I discussed a green datacentre company that drilled bores 220m into the ground to extract cold water for HVAC cooling systems. Cold water was pumped up, and hot water forced back down  a more efficient method than traditional air-conditioning.

The key concern raised was about the heat sink capability: as hot water is pumped into the underground aquifer, it creates a expanding "hot bubble" that could eventually compromise the cooling system's effectiveness.

Thermodynamic Reality

While the geologists claimed sufficient flow capacity, I argue that this approach is merely a delaying tactic. Ultimately, the energy must go somewhere, following the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics.

The fundamental issue remains: energy consumption in datacentres creates heat, and that heat must be dissipated somewhere. Whether it's:

• Traditional air conditioning systems pumping hot air outside
• Water cooling systems transferring heat to rivers or seas
• Geothermal systems pushing heat underground
• Waste heat recovery systems capturing energy for other uses

All these approaches simply move the problem elsewhere rather than solving it at its source.

The Marketing vs. Reality Problem

The conclusion is that such "green" solutions are often more about marketing than true environmental sustainability, potentially contributing to long-term environmental challenges.

True sustainability in the datacentre industry requires:

• Energy efficiency at the hardware level
• Renewable energy sources powering operations
• Innovative cooling technologies that minimize environmental impact
• Honest assessment of environmental costs rather than greenwashing

Until we address the fundamental energy requirements of our digital infrastructure, we're simply moving the environmental burden around rather than reducing it.

All Posts